New York’s lawsuit against Kalshi is back in state court, and the state is again asking a judge to stop the prediction market from offering sports contracts in New York. A federal court in Manhattan sent the case back this week. On Friday, November 20, Attorney General Letitia James renewed her request for a temporary restraining order (TRO). Justice Melissa Crane of the New York Supreme Court set a hearing for Monday, November 23.
How the case got here
James sued KalshiEX in state court in July 2026. The suit says Kalshi’s sports event contracts are illegal gambling under New York law, including contracts on games involving New York college teams and sports wagering by people under 21. ABC News reports that it does not seek to shut Kalshi down, but it could force the company to change how it operates.
Kalshi moved the case to federal court. Justice Crane turned down the state’s first TRO request in August without prejudice, which left the state free to try again if the case came back. US District Judge Vernon Broderick has now sent it back. He found that prediction markets do not automatically fall outside state jurisdiction, but he did not decide whether Kalshi’s contracts break New York law.
What the state is asking for
According to the proposed order, Kalshi would be barred from offering contracts on sports, culture, elections and other events “within or from New York or to persons in New York” without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. The order would also bar sales to anyone under 21 and restrict advertising, including on college campuses.
The “from New York” part is what worries Kalshi most, because the company is headquartered in the state. Its lawyer, Sean Murphy, told the court the order would likely force it to liquidate all open positions, with effects well beyond New York. A Kalshi spokesperson said 1.2 million New Yorkers use the platform.
The federal government steps in, and loses
Late on Friday, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) asked US District Judge Lorna Schofield in an emergency phone hearing to stop the state court from ruling. Its lawyer argued that the order would shut down Kalshi’s operations nationwide. Kate Rhodes Janofsky, for the attorney general, said Kalshi had shown no evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption. Schofield denied the application.
The CFTC is already suing several states over how they regulate event contracts, including Arkansas and Louisiana (see our earlier story). This week the Fourth Circuit also ruled against Kalshi in its Maryland case, the third federal appeals court to do so (see our report on that ruling).
What it means for players
Nothing changes until Justice Crane rules. If she grants the order, New York users could lose access to Kalshi’s sports contracts, and Kalshi says open positions would likely have to be liquidated rather than held to settlement. Because the order would reach activity run “from New York,” users in other states could be affected too.
Kalshi is not licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission, so the state’s gambling protections, such as its self-exclusion program and licensed-operator complaint routes, do not apply to it. If you hold open positions, keep track of the Monday hearing and Kalshi’s own notices. Legal sports betting in New York is available through the state-licensed sportsbooks on our US betting sites page, and our legal states map shows where each state stands.
Sources
- Administration tries to intervene after Kalshi is threatened with restraining order (ABC News)
- Kalshi races to get ahead of New York order that could shut down exchange (CoinDesk)
- CDC Gaming: Inside the latest prediction market news (CDC Gaming Reports)
Written in our own words from the sources above. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it and log it on our corrections page.

About the author
The BettingSeeker News Desk covers regulation, operator news and safer gambling developments in the UK, the US and Canada. Every story is based on primary sources such as regulator announcements, government publications and company filings, or on reporting by established news outlets, and every source is linked at the end of the article.
- Gambling regulation in the UK, US and Canada
- Sports betting and online casino legalisation
- Operator and industry news