Regulation · Canada

Supreme Court of Canada hears challenge to Ontario's shared poker liquidity plan

Canada's top court heard arguments on October 7 over whether Ontario can pool regulated online poker and DFS players with players abroad. Judgment is reserved.

The Supreme Court of Canada heard arguments on October 7 in a case that will decide whether players on Ontario’s regulated online poker sites can be seated at the same virtual tables as players in other countries. The hearing, in Atlantic Lottery Corporation et al. v. Attorney General of Ontario, lasted close to three hours, and the court has reserved its judgment.

The question before the court

Since Ontario opened its regulated iGaming market in April 2022, its online poker rooms have been ring-fenced. Players licensed through iGaming Ontario can only play against other people in the province. Ontario wants to change that by letting operators pool players with other regulated jurisdictions, an arrangement known as shared liquidity. The proposal also covers daily fantasy sports, where players compete against each other rather than against the house.

The legal issue turns on section 207(1)(a) of the Criminal Code. It allows a provincial government to “conduct and manage” gaming within its own province. The question is whether Ontario can still be said to conduct and manage a game when some of the people taking part are outside Canada and playing under another jurisdiction’s rules.

How the case got here

In November 2025, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled 4-1 that the province’s proposed model would be lawful under certain conditions. Several provincial lottery corporations that still run their own monopoly online offerings appealed that decision. The group is led by Atlantic Lottery Corporation and includes the British Columbia Lottery Corporation, Manitoba Liquor and Lotteries and Loto-Québec.

The court’s docket lists four interveners: the Attorney General of Alberta (the province opened its own competitive iGaming market in July), the Canadian Gaming Association, Flutter Entertainment and NSUS Group.

The arguments

Ontario’s lawyers argued that the province can conduct and manage games offered to its residents even when some participants are abroad, and that pooling players would not hand over its authority. They added that players from other Canadian provinces could only take part through agreements between provincial governments.

The appellants argued that the Criminal Code does not let provinces run schemes with international participation in the way Ontario proposes. They also warned that Ontario-licensed operators could use the province as a “springboard” to reach players elsewhere in Canada without local approval.

Justices pressed both sides. Justice Malcolm Rowe questioned whether contracts with international partners amount to conducting and managing a game, and Justice Mahmud Jamal asked whether every part of a gaming activity must take place inside Ontario.

What it means for players

Nothing changes for now. Ontario’s poker rooms remain limited to players in the province until the court rules, and there is no announced date for a decision.

If Ontario wins, players could eventually see bigger tournament fields, larger prize pools and more tables running at quieter times, since liquidity is the main limit on a ring-fenced poker market. Any international pooling would still need agreements with partner jurisdictions and regulatory approval, so it would not happen overnight. Players in other provinces would not automatically gain access. If you play poker online, use only operators registered in your province. Our glossary explains common poker and betting terms.

Sources

  1. Case 42141: Atlantic Lottery Corporation, et al. v. Attorney General of Ontario (Supreme Court of Canada)
  2. Canada's Supreme Court hears Ontario online poker case (Pokerfuse)

Written in our own words from the sources above. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it and log it on our corrections page.

About the author

BettingSeeker News DeskNews

The BettingSeeker News Desk covers regulation, operator news and safer gambling developments in the UK, the US and Canada. Every story is based on primary sources such as regulator announcements, government publications and company filings, or on reporting by established news outlets, and every source is linked at the end of the article.

  • Gambling regulation in the UK, US and Canada
  • Sports betting and online casino legalisation
  • Operator and industry news
View profile